Early Decision and Early Action results usually arrive in mid-December, and Regular Decision results in March and April. Not every answer is a yes. Whatever you hear, the next step is the same: read the decision letter carefully, note any deadline in it and keep your other applications moving. No one, including us, can tell you how a deferral or a waitlist will turn out, so plan for every outcome at once.
ContentsThe three decisions at a glance
| Decision | What it means | Your first step |
|---|---|---|
| Deferred | No decision yet. The college will review you again with a later round, usually Regular Decision. | Read the deferral letter and do exactly what it asks. |
| Waitlisted | Not admitted for now. You may be offered a place if spaces open after admitted students reply. | Accept or decline the waitlist spot, and commit to a college that admitted you. |
| Denied | Not admitted this cycle. | Focus on your remaining applications and offers. |
If you’re deferred
A deferral is a pause, not a verdict. The college wants to see you alongside the full applicant pool, often with your senior-year grades in hand. The University of Georgia, for example, tells deferred applicants not to reapply and not to pay another fee, and to send updates through its Application Update Form.
- Follow each college’s instructions. Some colleges send a form for updates, some ask for nothing new and some set a date for updates. Do what that college asks, in the format it asks for.
- Make sure your mid-year report goes out. On the Common App, your school counselor submits the Mid-Year Report with your first-semester or first-trimester grades. Not every college requires it, so check each one, and ask your counselor when it will be sent. Keep your grades strong; a deferral often means the college wants to see them.
- Send a short letter of continued interest only if the college allows it. If it does, keep it to a few paragraphs: you still want to attend, here is what is new, and if the college is your first choice and you would enroll if admitted, you can say so honestly.
- Send only new information worth sending. A major award, a new leadership role, a significant project, or higher test scores at a college that uses them. Not a rewritten essay or a list of small updates.
- Don’t flood the office. One well-timed update beats weekly emails. Extra recommendation letters, unrequested materials and repeated calls rarely help and can annoy busy staff.
Then finish your other applications as if the deferral were a no. That isn’t pessimism. It keeps your options open.
Early Decision vs. Early Action deferrals
Early Action deferral: nothing changes about your commitments, because EA was never binding. If you are admitted later, you can compare offers until May 1.
Early Decision deferral: NACAC recommends that colleges release an Early Decision applicant who is “deferred to an admission date other than that stated on the original application,” and a deferral to Regular Decision is one. Cornell, for example, states that students whose early decision applications are postponed to regular decision are released from the binding commitment. That means you can apply ED II elsewhere if you want, and an admission from the regular round is no longer binding at a college with that policy. NACAC’s guide is a set of recommendations and each college writes its own agreement, so read your deferral letter or ask the admissions office directly. If a college invites you to move into another binding round, such as ED II, that is a new commitment. Our guide to Early Decision vs. Early Action explains how each plan works.
If you’re waitlisted
NACAC describes a wait list as neither an offer nor a denial: the college extends the possibility of admission if space becomes available. Colleges usually don’t know whether they will admit from the list until admitted students reply around May 1, and some move well into the summer. Grinnell College, for example, says it typically releases its waitlist once enrollment numbers are stable in early July.
- Accept the spot if you still want the college. Most colleges ask you to opt in by a deadline. If you would not attend, decline so the spot goes to someone else.
- Deposit somewhere by May 1. NACAC recommends that colleges not charge a deposit or fee to stay on a wait list, and it is unethical to hold enrollment deposits at more than one U.S. college at the same time. So commit to a college that admitted you, by its deadline. If a waitlist offer comes later and you accept it, expect to lose that first deposit; NACAC recommends that admission offers state whether the deposit is refundable.
- Update once, through the college’s channel. Many colleges offer a waitlist form. Grinnell asks students not to request interviews or send extra recommendation letters.
- Ask about history and aid. NACAC recommends that colleges share how many students they have admitted from the wait list in past years, along with housing and financial aid availability. Aid can differ: Grinnell offers waitlist admits the same need-based aid as other admitted students, while Harvey Mudd says merit scholarships are not available to them.
How many waitlisted students are admitted varies widely by college and by year. In NACAC’s 2019 State of College Admission report, covering fall 2018, colleges admitted an average of 20 percent of students who chose to stay on wait lists, and the most selective colleges (those accepting fewer than half of applicants) admitted 7 percent. Those are averages across many colleges in one year. They are not your odds at any one college, and a college can admit no one from its list in a given year.
If you’re denied
A denial hurts, and it’s fine to take a day or two. Then turn back to the colleges where you are still in the running. A denial at one college says little about how you will do in college, and it is not a judgment of your worth.
Appeals are rare and narrow. Many colleges don’t accept appeals at all, and those that do look for specific circumstances, such as an error in your file or significant information that wasn’t in the application. UCLA, for example, accepted first-year appeals for fall 2026 between April 1 and 15, reviews each one case by case, says the number of decisions reversed is typically very low, and does not treat senior-year grades, recent awards or new activities as grounds for reversal. Check the college’s own policy before you write anything.
Transfer is a real path. Many students start at another four-year college or a community college and transfer later. Some colleges also offer guaranteed transfer admission or admission for a later term instead of fall, which NACAC calls a college-initiated deferral. Read our guide to transferring to a four-year college for how to make your credits count.
Keep your momentum
- Compare financial aid offers side by side. Look at grants and scholarships, which you don’t repay, separately from loans and work-study. NACAC recommends that colleges not ask you to commit before you have their financial aid offer. Our guide to paying for college after the 2026 changes covers the FAFSA, the CSS Profile and how to appeal an aid offer, and our guide to deciding where to enroll walks through net price, deposits and housing.
- Visit the colleges that admitted you. Admitted-student days, a class visit or a virtual session can make your choice clearer than any ranking.
- Track every deadline. Housing, deposits, aid documents, waitlist replies and placement tests all have dates. Keep them in one calendar.
What parents can do
- Lead with support. Your student will take cues from your reaction. Separate the decision from the person.
- Let your student write to the college. Letters of continued interest and waitlist updates should come from the applicant. Parents calling on a student’s behalf rarely helps.
- Own the money questions. Gather tax documents, file or correct the FAFSA and CSS Profile where required, and build a side-by-side cost comparison.
- Celebrate the admits. A family that is excited about the options it has makes May 1 much easier.
A timeline for the rest of senior year
| When | What happens | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| December | Many ED and EA decisions arrive, often in mid-December. | Read each letter. Submit remaining Regular Decision and ED II applications. |
| January–February | Mid-year reports go out. Many colleges set dates for deferral updates. | Confirm your counselor is sending the Mid-Year Report. Send one update if the college allows it. |
| March–April | Regular Decision results and financial aid offers arrive. | Accept or decline waitlist spots. Compare aid. Visit admitted colleges. |
| May 1 | National Candidates Reply Date, the earliest deadline NACAC recommends colleges set for an enrollment decision. | Deposit at one college that admitted you. Tell the others you won’t attend. Confirm each college’s exact deadline and time zone; May 1, 2027 falls on a Saturday. |
| May–August | Waitlist offers, if any. NACAC recommends colleges give at least 48 hours to respond after May 1 and send final waitlist decisions by August 1. | Respond quickly to any offer. If you switch, withdraw from your first college and expect to lose its deposit. |
Common mistakes to avoid
- Pausing other applications while you wait on a deferral or a waitlist.
- Missing the May 1 deposit because you are holding out for a waitlist answer.
- Holding more than one deposit. NACAC counts that as unethical. Pick one college and tell the others.
- Sending everything. More material is not more persuasive. New and meaningful is.
- Letting grades slip. Colleges see your mid-year and final grades. Read the conditions in every admission letter.
- Trusting anyone who quotes your odds. No calculator or consultant can tell you whether a deferral or a waitlist will turn into an admission. Here is why no one can predict your chances.
Want help weighing your offers or planning a transfer? Our free assessment builds a timeline for your remaining deadlines, and Admit Preparation helps you plan the next step.
Sources
- Guide to Ethical Practice in College Admission, 2026 Edition, National Association for College Admission Counseling.
- 2019 State of College Admission, National Association for College Admission Counseling.
- Does Cornell have early decision?, Cornell University Undergraduate Admissions.
- Deferred Applicant FAQs, University of Georgia Undergraduate Admissions.
- Waitlist, Grinnell College Office of Admission.
- Waitlist FAQs, Harvey Mudd College Office of Admission and Financial Aid.
- Appeals to First-Year Admission Decisions, UCLA Undergraduate Admission.
- Common App Mid-Year Report, 2025–26, Common App (via Northwestern University).
- How To Evaluate Your Aid Offers, Federal Student Aid, U.S. Department of Education.