Spring of senior year brings decisions, aid offers and invitations to admitted-student days, often all in the same few weeks. This guide takes them in the order you’ll need them: the deadline, the money, the visit, the data and the rules that apply once you say yes. If you’re still waiting on a deferral or a waitlist, start with our guide to being deferred, waitlisted or denied.

Contents

May 1: the National Candidates Reply Date

The National Association for College Admission Counseling (NACAC) recommends, in its Guide to Ethical Practice in College Admission (2026 edition, last updated August 2026), that colleges use May 1 as the earliest enrollment confirmation deadline. Before you’re asked to commit, NACAC says you should have heard from each college that admitted you about:

  • its offer of financial aid and scholarships,
  • admission to honors and other special programs, and
  • the availability of housing.

NACAC also recommends that you not be required to confirm enrollment until a college has told you about all its aid and scholarship offers, and that admission offers say whether the deposit is refundable. Students admitted Early Action or Restrictive Early Action should have until May 1 as well. The recognized exceptions are binding Early Decision and recipients of athletic scholarships.

Two cautions. First, these are recommendations: since 2020 NACAC’s guide has been a statement of recommended practices rather than enforceable membership rules, so a college can set its own date. Read your admission letter. Second, check the clock. NACAC asks colleges to say whether an online deadline is in your time zone or theirs. UCLA, for example, required its Statement of Intent to Register, and, if required, a $250 registration deposit that isn’t refundable, by 11:59 p.m. Pacific time on May 1, 2026, and gave students admitted close to or after that date three days from their admission letter. May 1, 2027 falls on a Saturday; don’t leave it to the last hour.

Compare aid offers on net price

Federal Student Aid notes that aid offers have no standardized format, so the same kind of money can carry different names at different colleges. Put every offer on the same basis before you compare:

  1. Start with the total cost. Use each college’s cost of attendance (tuition, fees, housing, food, books, transportation and personal costs), then add costs it leaves out. Studentaid.gov’s example is a longer commute.
  2. Subtract only grants and scholarships. Studentaid.gov’s formula: total cost minus grants and scholarships equals your net price. Compare net price, not the sticker price.
  3. List work-study and loans separately. Work-study is money you earn at a job you have to find; it isn’t guaranteed and arrives as a paycheck, not a credit on your first bill. Loans are borrowed and repaid with interest.
  4. Check the conditions. Does each scholarship renew every year? Is there a minimum GPA or a required major? Is a grant for the first year only?
  5. Look four years ahead. Multiply by the years you expect to need, and ask how the college handles cost increases.

Our aid offer comparison tool does this arithmetic for you: enter each college’s cost, grants and loans to see net price, out-of-pocket cost and four-year totals side by side. It runs entirely in your browser.

Grants are discounts; loans are not

A college can close the gap between its cost and what your family can pay with grants, or with loans. The offers can look similar on a page and cost you very different amounts. A few facts help:

  • Federal student loans have fixed rates that change each year for new loans. For Direct Subsidized and Unsubsidized Loans first disbursed from July 1, 2026 to June 30, 2027, the undergraduate rate is 6.52%, plus a loan fee of 1.057% taken out of each disbursement. Interest on unsubsidized loans starts right away. If you start in fall 2027, your first loans will most likely be paid out after July 1, 2027, at the 2027–⁠28 rate, which isn’t set until late spring 2027; use 6.52% as an estimate until then.
  • Parent PLUS loans are the parent’s debt, not the student’s. For loans first disbursed from July 1, 2026 to June 30, 2027 the rate is 9.07%. Since July 1, 2026, all parents together can borrow at most $20,000 a year and $65,000 in total for each dependent student. That applies to every family of a student starting college in fall 2027; only students who were already enrolled in their program and had a federal Direct Loan for it (their own or a Parent PLUS) before July 1, 2026 can keep the old limit, the cost of attendance minus other aid, for a limited time. See our guide to paying for college after the 2026 changes.
  • You can take less. Studentaid.gov suggests accepting aid in order: grants and scholarships first, then work-study, then loans (subsidized before unsubsidized, and those before PLUS). It also says you have the right to turn down a loan or ask for a lower amount, and that many colleges offer tuition payment plans that can reduce how much you borrow.
  • Private loans fill gaps last. They may require a cosigner and a credit history, and may not offer the repayment options that federal loans do.

If an offer doesn’t work for your family

If your family’s finances have changed, or the FAFSA doesn’t capture them, ask the aid office for a professional judgment review, with documents. If another college offered more, some colleges will review their own grants in light of a competing offer, but that’s each college’s policy, not a federal rule. Our guide to appealing a financial aid offer explains both requests and what to send.

Timing matters. Ask as soon as offers arrive. If a review is still open as your deadline approaches, ask the admission office, in writing, whether it can extend your reply date, and get the answer in writing too.

Visit before you decide, if you can

Many colleges hold admitted-student days or overnight programs in April, when you can sit in on a class, talk to current students and see the housing you’d live in. Some help with travel. Harvard, for example, offered need-based travel assistance to some admitted students for Visitas, its April 2026 admitted-student program; it covered the student’s travel, not family members’, and Harvard says it can’t fund every student. If a trip is out of reach, ask whether the college has virtual sessions, or can put you in touch with a current student or a professor in your intended major. Our guide to visiting when you can’t afford to travel has more options.

On a visit, ask the questions that only that college can answer:

  • How many first-year students get the classes they want, and how hard is it to get into your intended major?
  • Is housing guaranteed for first-year students, and for how many years?
  • What do students actually spend on books, food and travel home?
  • Where do students go for tutoring, health care, mental health support and disability accommodations, and what do those cost?

Check outcomes with College Scorecard

The U.S. Department of Education’s College Scorecard shows the same measures for every college that takes federal aid, which makes it a useful check on brochures. Know what each number measures:

  • Average annual cost is the average net price for full-time, first-time students who receive federal aid, and only the in-state figure at public colleges. Scorecard also breaks it out by family income, which is closer to what a family like yours paid. Your own aid offer is still the number that counts.
  • Graduation rate is the share of entering students who graduated from that college within eight years, whether they started full time or part time. The same section shows how many students return after their first year, and how many transferred or withdrew.
  • Median total debt after graduation covers undergraduate federal loans taken at that college by borrowers who finished. It leaves out Parent PLUS and private loans, and Scorecard shows a typical monthly payment on a 10-year plan.
  • Median earnings count former students who received federal aid, were working and weren’t enrolled in school. The current figures follow students who finished in 2017–⁠18 and 2018–⁠19, measured in 2022 and 2023 and adjusted to 2024 dollars.

Every one of these is an average over many students in past years, mostly federal aid recipients. Use them to compare colleges and to ask good questions, not to predict your own result. Earnings and debt also vary by major, which Scorecard reports by field of study; our guide to choosing a major explains that data, and our guide to reading a Common Data Set shows where colleges publish more.

Fit: what the numbers don’t show

Studentaid.gov’s own advice is to weigh things that matter to you alongside cost: class size, location, campus community, a college’s mission or religious affiliation. A few questions help when two offers look close:

  • Can you afford all four years without borrowing more than you’re comfortable with, even if your family’s situation changes?
  • Can you study what you want there, including a second choice if your first major doesn’t work out?
  • Will you get support? First-generation programs, advising, and accommodations if you need them. Our guides for first-generation students and on moving from an IEP to college accommodations list questions to ask.
  • How far is home, and what does it cost to get there for breaks?
  • When you picture yourself there in October, not just on a sunny visit day, does it feel right?

If you were admitted Early Decision

Early Decision is different. NACAC describes it as the only application plan in which students are required to accept an offer and submit a deposit before May 1: you agreed to enroll if admitted and to withdraw your other applications. On the Common App, you and your counselor sign the Early Decision agreement, and so does a parent or guardian if they have an email address.

NACAC recommends that colleges release an Early Decision applicant who is denied, deferred to a later admission date, offered a different program or major than the one applied to, or not offered a financial aid award that makes attendance possible. If an ED offer truly doesn’t work for your family, talk to the aid office first, then to the admission office, before the college’s deposit deadline. Our guide to Early Decision vs. Early Action covers the plans in detail.

Deposit at one college, and tell the others

A deposit (or an equivalent written commitment) confirms that you intend to enroll. NACAC’s guide asks counselors to tell students that it is unethical to hold an active enrollment deposit at more than one U.S. college at the same time, and unethical not to tell colleges whose offers you are declining. Common App applicants affirm the same thing when they submit each application:

“I affirm that I will send an enrollment deposit (or equivalent) to only one institution; sending multiple deposits (or equivalent) may result in the withdrawal of my admission offers from all institutions.”

Common App notes one exception: if a college admits you from its waitlist, you may deposit there as well, provided you tell the first college that you won’t be enrolling.

Holding two deposits “to decide later” keeps someone else waiting for your place and risks both offers. Once you’ve deposited, decline your other offers through each college’s portal. It takes a minute and frees places for students on waitlists.

If the deposit is a hardship, ask the admission office before the deadline whether it can be waived or deferred.

If you’re still on a waitlist

Don’t let a waitlist cost you a place elsewhere. Deposit at a college that admitted you by its deadline, and stay on the waitlist only for colleges you would choose over it. NACAC recommends that colleges:

  • not charge a deposit or fee for staying on a waitlist;
  • give students offered admission from the waitlist after May 1 at least 48 hours before requiring a commitment;
  • tell you your aid offer and housing availability before asking you to commit; and
  • send final waitlist decisions by August 1.

If you accept a waitlist offer, withdraw from the college where you deposited and expect to lose that deposit unless it was refundable. Our guide to waitlists covers updates and what to ask.

Deferring your start or taking a gap year

NACAC calls a student-requested deferral, often for a gap year, “deferred enrollment.” Colleges grant these requests at their discretion, should state their policies, and may forbid deferred students from taking college classes elsewhere in the meantime. Policies range from routine approval to rare exceptions. UCLA, for example, says it doesn’t grant many deferrals: it generally limits them to medical conditions, military service and religious missions, takes requests only through its portal between April 1 and August 15, and doesn’t allow college courses during the deferral.

At most colleges you commit first, by the normal deadline, and then request the deferral; get the approval and its conditions in writing before you decline other offers. Expect to apply for need-based aid again for the year you actually start, and ask whether merit scholarships carry over. Our guide to taking a gap year compares college policies and covers planning the year.

After you commit: housing, final grades and summer deadlines

  • Housing has its own deadlines and deposits. NACAC asks colleges to publish housing deadlines and policies, including any guarantee. At the University of Pittsburgh, for example, first-year students admitted for fall 2026 who paid the $300 enrollment fee by May 1 and the $325 housing deposit by their due date were guaranteed housing for at least two years; students who paid later joined a waitlist served in order of application date. Find your college’s housing page the day you deposit.
  • Your offer is conditional. Common App applicants affirm that “all offers of admission are conditional, pending receipt of final transcripts showing work comparable in quality to that upon which the offer was based.” Finish senior year at the level you were admitted on, and tell the college right away if something changes, such as a dropped course.
  • Accept your aid and finish the paperwork. Follow your college’s steps to accept your aid offer. First-time federal borrowers complete entrance counseling and sign a Master Promissory Note. Send any verification documents the aid office asks for.
  • Keep a summer calendar. Orientation, placement tests, health forms, the first bill and final transcripts all have dates. Students who miss them sometimes never enroll, a pattern called summer melt.

A short decision checklist

  1. List every offer with its reply deadline, time zone and whether the deposit is refundable.
  2. Enter each aid offer in the comparison tool: net price for one year and four, and loans listed separately.
  3. Ask for a review now if an offer doesn’t reflect your finances, and ask for an extension in writing if you need one.
  4. Visit, in person or virtually, the two or three colleges you’re deciding among.
  5. Check each one’s Scorecard graduation rate, net price for your income, debt and earnings.
  6. If you applied Early Decision, follow that agreement; if you’re waitlisted, deposit elsewhere anyway.
  7. Deposit at one college by its deadline, and decline your other offers.
  8. Apply for housing, accept your aid and put every summer deadline on a calendar.

Want someone to talk it through with? Our free assessment builds a timeline for your remaining deadlines, and the college checklist lists each spring step. Unfamiliar terms are in the glossary.

Sources

  1. Guide to Ethical Practice in College Admission, 2026 Edition (last updated August 2026), National Association for College Admission Counseling. Accessed October 22, 2026.
  2. Useful College Admission Terms, National Association for College Admission Counseling. Accessed October 22, 2026.
  3. Application affirmations, Common App. Accessed October 22, 2026.
  4. What are the Early Decision requirements?, Common App Student Solutions Center. Accessed October 22, 2026.
  5. Accepting Your Offer of Admission — First-Years (Statement of Intent to Register, deposit and deferments), UCLA Undergraduate Admission. Accessed October 22, 2026.
  6. How To Evaluate Your Aid Offers, Federal Student Aid, U.S. Department of Education. Accessed October 22, 2026.
  7. Accepting Financial Aid, Federal Student Aid, U.S. Department of Education. Accessed October 22, 2026.
  8. Subsidized and Unsubsidized Loans (2026–⁠27 interest rates, loan fee, entrance counseling and Master Promissory Note), Federal Student Aid, U.S. Department of Education. Accessed October 22, 2026.
  9. Parent PLUS Loans (2026–⁠27 interest rate and limits for new borrowers), Federal Student Aid, U.S. Department of Education. Accessed October 22, 2026.
  10. College Scorecard glossary (average annual cost, graduation rate, median debt and median earnings), U.S. Department of Education. Accessed October 22, 2026.
  11. College Scorecard (school profiles: cost by family income, retention, outcomes eight years after entry, monthly loan payment), U.S. Department of Education. Accessed October 22, 2026.
  12. Harvard-Funded Travel for Visitas, Harvard College. Accessed October 22, 2026.
  13. First Year Application Process (2026–⁠27 guaranteed housing), Panther Central, University of Pittsburgh. Accessed October 22, 2026.

Sources checked October 22, 2026.