Many colleges ask for more writing than the personal statement: short essays, short answers and sometimes a list. The usual questions ask why you want this college, what you would study there or what you would bring. For the main essay, see our guide to writing your personal statement.
ContentsWhere supplements live in the Common App
Common App’s first-year guide names three places for essays and short answers. The personal essay, which each college makes required or optional, is in the writing section of My Common Application, along with a table of each college’s requirements. College-specific questions sit in each college’s own section, and Common App says many colleges include short-answer questions or essay prompts there. Some colleges also use a separate writing supplement, and some request it only based on your answers to other questions. For a writing supplement, Common App says you must submit your application to that college first; then you can review and submit the supplement.
Names vary. Columbia calls its questions “Columbia-specific questions, also known as the writing supplement,” while Yale tells Common App applicants to answer its questions in the “My Colleges” section. To plan, use Common App’s writing requirements by college, which lists each college’s questions, whether each is required or optional, and its minimum and maximum word count.
For 2026–27, Common App told counselors in May 2026 that colleges can tailor their questions to your answers to about 30 questions in My Common Application, which can reduce duplicate questions in the college-specific sections. If you change one of those answers, recheck each college’s section.
The common types of question
Many prompts fall into a few types. Common App’s bank of standard questions that colleges can add (the posted version is labeled 2025–26) includes “Why are you interested in [Member Name]?” and “Discuss your reasons for pursuing the [Major/Academic Program] selected above.” The examples below are quoted from colleges’ own pages. They show what each type looks like, not what to write.
Why this college
Columbia asks the same question in 150 words. A good answer connects particular things the college offers to things you have done or want to do; the research section covers how to find them.
Why this major or academic area
Yale has you choose up to three academic areas, then write up to 200 words about a related topic or idea that excites you. You don’t need to be certain; Yale’s question itself notes that many students modify their original direction or change their minds entirely. Show what draws you to the subject and how you have explored it.
Community and belonging
Yale offers a similar 400-word option and says you may define community however you like. Duke’s has three parts. Mark each one and check that your draft answers all of them.
An activity or responsibility
Some colleges ask you to describe one activity or responsibility, which can be a job or something you do for your family, not only a club. Your activities list already says what you did; use the essay for one activity and what you noticed, decided or changed while doing it.
Short answers and lists
Columbia asks for items separated by commas or semicolons and says no author names, subtitles or explanatory remarks are needed. Some are much shorter: Yale’s Common App applicants answer three questions in 200 characters or fewer (about 35 words), and Princeton’s “More About You” questions, such as “What brings you joy?”, allow 50 words each. Give a plain, true answer rather than a clever one that isn’t you, and list only things you have actually read, watched or used. If you interview, you may be asked about what you wrote; our guide to college interviews suggests rereading your application first.
Researching a college so “why us” is specific
Start with what you want to do, then look for where the college makes it possible in what it publishes:
- The course catalog or bulletin. Look up courses in your likely field, and make sure any course you mention is in the current catalog.
- Department pages. Read what each says about its undergraduate program: requirements, research opportunities and how students declare the major.
- The college’s structure. If the prompt names schools, as Duke’s does with Trinity and Pratt, find out how they differ and which one you are applying to.
- How programs are entered. Some programs select students after they enroll. Duke says indicating interest in its Duke Embark program on the application is not an application to the program or a guarantee of acceptance; admitted students apply after enrolling. Write about what you would pursue, not what you assume you will get.
- Your own notes. Jennifer Keegan, senior associate director of admissions at Bryn Mawr, suggests in an undated college article taking notes during visits, in person or virtual, on what stood out, such as a professor or student you met, and drawing on them when a question asks why you applied.
Then cut. For each detail, write a sentence linking it to something you have done or want to do; if you can’t, drop it. Two or three details tied to you say more than every course that sounds interesting, and reputation alone tells a reader nothing about you.
Reusing material without writing generic answers
Similar questions come up at many colleges, so reuse raw material, not finished answers. Keep one document of stories, activities, interests and notes on each college, and start each new prompt from that document rather than from another college’s essay.
Duke and Yale both ask about a community, for example, and the same community might suit both. But Duke allows 250 words and asks what you hope to bring to Duke, while Yale allows 400 and asks why the community is meaningful to you. An answer cut or stretched to fit the other usually misses part of the question.
Keegan notes in the same article that supplemental questions are often institution-specific, “so this is not a time to pull from other supplemental essays,” and that it helps if a supplement doesn’t draw from the same topic as the application essay. Map which story goes where, so each piece shows a reader something new. Write every “why us” answer fresh, and after pasting anything, search it for other colleges’ names.
Word limits
Limits vary even within one college’s questions. Princeton’s range from 50 words to a “Your Voice” essay of 400 to 500 words, which sets a minimum as well as a maximum. Yale counts characters for its shortest answers. Treat each maximum as a limit, not a goal: draft long if that helps, then cut to the strongest point. A very short answer has room for one idea and a reason.
Optional essays
Whether to write an optional essay depends on what the college says. Duke’s 2026–27 application offers three optional prompts and says: “We want to emphasize that the following questions are optional. We invite you to answer one of the three if you believe that doing so will add something meaningful that is not already addressed elsewhere in your application.”
If you have something meaningful the rest of your application doesn’t show, an optional essay is a place for it; if you would only repeat yourself, leave it blank. If a college doesn’t say how it treats optional responses, don’t rely on forum posts; ask its admissions office.
The additional information section
Common App’s help center says you may use the Additional Information prompt in the writing section “to share relevant information about yourself that is not captured elsewhere in the application.” When Common App announced its 2025–26 changes, it cut the first-year limit from 650 to 300 words and kept the separate challenges and circumstances question at 250. Common App’s 2026 first-year application PDF shows both limits for 2026–27. Our personal statement guide covers what belongs there.
It isn’t overflow space for a supplement that ran long, and it isn’t the place for one college’s “why us” answer, because it sits in My Common Application rather than in any college’s section.
Our ethics, and what the rules say about AI
Common App’s fraud policy (last updated August 2023) lists among the circumstances in which fraud may occur “submitting plagiarized essays or other written or oral material, or intentionally misrepresenting as one’s own original work: (1) another person’s thoughts, language, ideas, expressions, or experiences or (2) the substantive content or output of an artificial intelligence platform, technology, or algorithm.” Short answers and lists are written material too. If Common App determines fraud occurred, it may suspend or terminate your account and disclose the fraud to the colleges on your My Colleges list. Harvard’s admissions FAQ adds that applicants must affirm, when they submit, that all information submitted in the admission process is “my own work, factually true, and honestly presented.”
Colleges add their own rules, and they differ; our personal statement guide gives examples of college AI policies. Read each college’s policy, and ask its admissions office if anything is unclear.
Verify everything yourself. Take each prompt from the college’s own page or the application, check that it is for 2026–27, and check every course and program you mention against the college’s own site, not a summary from a tool or another website.
Planning the work
Supplements add up, so count each college’s questions when you finalize your list and schedule the writing time. Our guide to building a balanced college list helps you choose schools you would actually attend, which makes “why us” answers easier to write honestly. The college admissions page covers essays in the wider application, and the glossary defines terms such as demonstrated interest.
Sources
- Application guide for first-year students, Common App. Accessed October 21, 2026.
- Writing requirements by college, Common App Student Solutions Center. Accessed October 21, 2026.
- When can I submit my Writing Supplement?, Common App Student Solutions Center. Accessed October 21, 2026.
- How can I add more information that isn’t covered in the Common App?, Common App Student Solutions Center. Accessed October 21, 2026.
- 2025–2026 first-year member screen questions, Common App Member Solutions Center. Accessed October 21, 2026.
- What’s new with Common App: 2026–27 first-year app updates for counselors and advisors (webinar slides), Common App, May 21, 2026.
- Can I get paper or PDF versions of the application and recommender forms?, Common App Student Solutions Center (links the 2026 first-year application PDF, which asks for a personal essay of no more than 650 words and gives a 250-word maximum for challenges and circumstances and 300 for additional information). Accessed October 22, 2026.
- Announcing the 2025–2026 Common App essay prompts, Common App, February 27, 2025 (additional information and challenges and circumstances limits).
- Fraud Policy, Common App, last updated August 2023. Accessed October 21, 2026.
- What help can students receive in writing their essays?, Harvard College Admissions Office (includes the certification applicants affirm). Accessed October 21, 2026.
- Apply, Duke Undergraduate Admissions (2026–27 essays and Duke Embark). Accessed October 21, 2026.
- Essay Topics, Yale Undergraduate Admissions (2026–2027). Accessed October 21, 2026.
- Columbia-Specific Application Questions, Columbia Undergraduate Admissions, updated July 28, 2026.
- Princeton-specific Questions, Princeton Office of Admission (2026–27). Accessed October 21, 2026.
- Mawr Insight: The Supplemental Essay, Bryn Mawr College (undated). Accessed October 21, 2026.